Buy new: $24.21
18 used and new from $9.65
Customer Rating:
First tagged "shakespeare" by CrabbyCats
See More Detail tags: macbeth, shakespeare, graphic novel
Product Description
Shakespeare’s classical play of dishonesty and murder is reinvented in a Japanese manga character and set on a immeasurable ringworld surrounding a sun. Artist Tony Tamai’s singular prophesy and character breathe new life into a enthralling classic.
Product Details
- Amazon Sales Rank: #3438179 in Books
- Published on: 2006-01
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: .60" h x 5.20" w x 7.98" l, .61 pounds
- Binding: Library Binding
- 148 pages
Editorial Reviews
From School Library Journal
Grade 9 Up–In this adaptation, a Weird Sisters are cloaked robots that pronounce in barcode, a soldiers horses are swift dragonlike creatures, and a letters to Lady Macbeth arrive around computer. Despite a intriguing intensity of this format and a updated setting, a book is disappointing. As a story opens, a black-and-white design is perplexing and appealing. However, readers unknown with a tract will have problem following a movement and a characters. Also, a peculiarity of a illustrations tends to mellow during pointless intervals. For example, in some scenes Lady Macbeth is cruelly summarized with thick black lines that demeanour like a work of an pledge manga artist, while in a same row her father appears remarkably drawn. Similarly, median by a murder of Lady Macduff, a character shifts abruptly, disrupting a upsurge of a panels. This science-fiction chronicle of a play competence be fun to use in a classroom to illustrate a timelessness of a Bards plays, though it is doubtful to find a far-reaching audience.–Heather M. Lisowski, Philip S. Miller Library, Castle Rock, CO
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a multiplication of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Gr. 6-9. Reimagining Macbeth as a space show seems a healthy approach to repackage a play as a striking novel. Cover maintains most of Shakespeare's discourse and infrequently relies on it to approach depictions of his characters in a art. Lady Macbeth, however, is a bit some-more chubby than she competence seem in a strange play, and in further to lots of cool, unconventional space armor, there's a dragon or dual in this version. The black-and-white images are full of movement and energy, and faces are transparent and distinct. An appendix provides readers with technical information on how a art was created. This is positively no surrogate for saying or conference a theatre play, though this visible take might make study a genuine thing distant reduction intimidating. Francisca Goldsmith
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
About a Author
Arthur Byron Cover lives in Northridge, California. Tony Leonard Tamai lives in Nagoya, Japan.
Customer Reviews
Most useful patron reviews
3 of 3 people found a following examination helpful.
The Luck of Macbeth Made Evident
By Brendan Collins
Being a shortest of Shakespearian tragedies, Macbeth would be a judicious choice of play to accept a striking novel treatment. This book, retelling a rather truncated chronicle of "the Scottish play," is one of a some-more new attempts that capitalizes on a psychic elements, while transposing a singular unconventional environment (the opening heading puts a story in "Stardate: 1040," a King's group float dragons, and even a Weird Sisters seem as androids).
However, there is a clear clarity that a finished product does not live adult to a initial aspirations. Though a content is unconditionally comprised of vicious lines gleaned from a strange content (including a few remaining nonetheless unconditionally noted ones, such as Macbeth's "We have destroyed a snake, not killed it" and a smart discourse between MacDuff's mother and child), a story does not keep a correct upsurge of a strange play. In bettering a story, too many has been mislaid for a consequence of brevity, and so are a characterizations fatally flawed. One feels small magnetism (much reduction empathy) with a comfortless favourite given his mutation from nobleness to brutality is roughly immediate, permitting no event to be drawn into his before hold virtue. In fact, a usually outline whose genocide we felt was that of Banquo (and Shakespeare's Macbeth is abundant with such unfair murder and assassination)!
Likewise, Mr. Tamai's design is competant during best, if inconsistent. The sensuous character of painting stays total for all of 55 pages before degenerating into a totally opposite one, as if a pages were deficient during a time of publication. The fluent eyes and shrewd fact lapse some twenty pages later, nonetheless shortly waste behind to a "new" style. It could be argued that this pointy change in sketch character is a microcosm deputy of Scotland's push into madness, nonetheless for such a purpose it is sadly ineffective.
Together, both a content and a painting spasmodic work opposite any other, providing not so many nominal story-telling techniques, nonetheless distraction. This is, unfortunately, generally distinguished in a initial few pages of a book, where a witches broach their opening lines and a King's fighting group pronounce poetically during a complex, heavily minute battle. The beauty of Shakespeare's difference are total with Mr. Tamai's illusory digest of a unconventional skirmish, nonetheless a dual yield such a juncture as to describe a high mountain of confusion.
Helpful would be some form of "spacing," or a use of separations signifying a breaks in a play's Acts (the brief book's "chapters," if we will). Also, a brief outline of a expel of characters would support a reader in perceptive who's who (since a book does run shorter than a play on that it is based, thereby formulating a diminutive window of event into that a uninformed reader might enter). Finally, a familiar believe of a strange play would support a reader in removing by a whole book, as a book by itself conjunction involves nor moves a reader.
It is a lofty end for Penguin Graphics to try such an adaptation, so it is generally unsatisfactory that such a intrepid bid should tumble so short.
1 of 1 people found a following examination helpful.
my review
By A Customer
"Macbeth a Graphic Novel"
I like a book to some extent, like a tract and graphics, nonetheless a rest of a book was rather boring. It's tedious due to a fact that it's been created hundreds of times before. There was zero new solely a comics used to illustrate a actions of a characters.
It was easily drawn out nonetheless 3 buliding of a approach through, a graphics became all messy and seemed to have been feeble drawn. It has many vast difference and aged English dialogue, so it might be difficult to some readers. we was means to sense many of a language, nonetheless many of it we only faded in and out.
The suspicion is crafty to set it in a Star Date 1040, and to supplement cinema to interest to younger readers, nonetheless they should only leave Shakespearean novel alone and keep it a approach it was intended.
Overall we deliberate a book boring and feeble suspicion out. But we give it an A+ for creativity and use of graphics and a mix of suspense, comedy, and tragedy. Although we don't suggest a book, due to a many flaws and bad graphics.
0 of 0 people found a following examination helpful.
good for a lulz
By pdRydia
As others have forked out, this is not a refined, discriminating product. It reads and looks like a rush job, nonetheless isn't bad adequate as to be incomprehensible--which is observant something, for Shakespeare. The comic doesn't offer many solely that holding Macbeth into a unconventional environment is good for a laugh.
I picked a book adult during a internal bookstore on sale for $3, and I'd contend it's value discount bin prices.
Also On shopping
No comments:
Post a Comment